With the rise in the popularity of portable oxygen concentrators, the number of different models, brands, and features available is also rising. Many of our customers zero in on the Philips SimplyGo and the Ingoen One G3 while searching a for a portable oxygen concentrator, and it can be tough to decide between these two units.
To help you make a selection that is best for your lifestyle we have compared two of our most popular concentrators the Respironics SimplyGo and Inogen One G3.
Oxygen Flow Settings and Capabilities
Of course, the first thing you want to look for in an oxygen concentrator is how it delivers and how much it delivers. The major difference between the two is that the Inogen One G3 offers only pulse dose operation, while the Respironics SimplyGo offers both pulse dose and continuous flow. G3 supports up to a setting of 5 on pulse dose. Whereas, SimplyGo supports up to a setting of 6 on pulse dose and 2 liters per minute on continuous flow.
If you currently require a unit that provides continuous flow 24/7 or you are looking for a unit that will cover your daytime and nighttime needs, the all-purpose Respironics SimplyGo should be considered. If you are looking for a concentrator that will help you get out-and-about and the pulse dose delivery covers your oxygen needs, the popular Inogen One G3 should be considered. If you couldn’t eliminate one based on these features, we have compared more features.
Weight and Size
Because the Respironics SimplyGo portable oxygen concentrator offers continuous flow, it is larger than the Inogen One G3 (it is about double in weight at 10 pounds compared to Inogen One G3’s 4.8 pounds). Both units come with a convenient carrying bag; the SimplyGo also comes with a carrying cart to compensate for its weight. Based on the feedback from some oxygen users, some feel that any weight carried is too much - even five pounds - and they prefer a unit with a cart.
Both of these units can operate on battery power and come with car and home adaptors. The Inogen One G3 has a longer life as well as the capability to operate two battery sizes. Inogen One G3’s larger (16-cell) battery can last up to 8 hours at a pulse-dose setting of 2. In contrast, the Respironics SimplyGo offers only one battery option, lasting about 3 hours at a pulse-dose setting of 2 and about 1.6 hours at a continuous-flow at 1 LPM. The Respironics SimplyGo does offer a higher oxygen output (2000 mL/min vs. the Inogen at 1050 mL/min), which is why the battery life isn’t as robust.
Side-by-Side Unit Comparison
Pulse dose: 1 to 6 setting
Pulse dose: 1 to 5 setting
Pulse dose: 3 hours, on setting of 2
Pulse dose: 8 hours, on setting of 2 with larger 16-cell battery
SimplyGo, from Philips, is a well-thought-out unit to accommodate your travel needs, making it the first choice for the travelers for a stress-free vacation. This reliable unit can give alerts in case of high breath rate, no breath detection, and low oxygen level.
Inogen Inc., which manufactures Inogen One G3, is specialized in developing oxygen concentrators. Inogen One G3 is robust, quiet and easy-to-maintain. This smart unit can give visual and audible alerts such as no breath detection, low battery and service needed.
The Final Choice: Respironics SimplyGo vs. Inogen One G3
The first consideration you will need to make is if you want a portable concentrator for day trips out of the house or a concentrator that can cover all of your oxygen needs. Choosing between the two POCs comes down to examining their differences: if you require continuous-flow oxygen, want a unit that covers your daytime and nighttime needs, and want a more robust unit, choose the Respironics SimplyGo. If you require only pulse-dose and want something easier to carry, the Inogen One G3 may be better for your lifestyle. Whichever you choose, you’ll know that you have a powerful and safe portable oxygen concentrator with you at all times.